A sheep, a werewolf and a walrus walk into a bar.
Round Table Discussion Thread - Printable Version

+- A sheep, a werewolf and a walrus walk into a bar. (https://forumofgames.com)
+-- Forum: Werewolf (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Forum: Werewolf Games (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: Round Table Discussion Thread (/showthread.php?tid=434)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Edward the Barber - 17-01-2023

(17-01-2023, 10:58 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote: Vote Dora
More flippage


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 17-01-2023

(17-01-2023, 10:59 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:
(17-01-2023, 10:58 PM)Dora the Explorer Wrote: You have to vote in the next thirty seconds for the above to hold zeena.
Your watch is fast But yeah 😜

Well I would've needed time to react, but zeena hasn't gone for it.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 17-01-2023

another coin flip.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Edward the Barber - 17-01-2023

(17-01-2023, 10:59 PM)Dora the Explorer Wrote:
(17-01-2023, 10:59 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Your watch is fast But yeah 😜

Well I would've needed time to react, but zeena hasn't gone for it.
Good luck 🤞


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 17-01-2023

All votes cast... Stand by


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 17-01-2023

May the faithful survive Edward 🙏


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Countess Markievicz - 17-01-2023

Fingers crossed


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Edward the Barber - 17-01-2023

If it's me I still believe Zena and friar with Gordon added last night


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 17-01-2023

I think we're both faithful anyway, so hit up the friar next folks.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Edward the Barber - 17-01-2023

(17-01-2023, 11:00 PM)Dora the Explorer Wrote: May the faithful survive Edward 🙏
Pretty sure this is village village


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Edward the Barber - 17-01-2023

Zena you should have gon friar for the lols


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 17-01-2023

I think so too, and I honestly would've gone friar too, even though I could've banished you.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 17-01-2023

Another day, another tie - once again the players cannot decide who to banish so it is left to the lords of randomisation....


   


Edward the Barber has trimmed his last haircut and been banished. Edward was another of the Faithful amongst you all.

[Image: giphy.gif]


See you in the morning everyone... but not all of you will make it there most likely. For the WITCHING HOUR is now in effect and the Traitors will meet to try and murder another of your numbers.


[Image: 0_image001JPG.jpg]


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 18-01-2023

Round Table Discussion is now OPEN


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - William the Grave Robber - 18-01-2023

Been watching the back and forth between Dora and Friar, my vote will definitely be going on one of them. Haven't had much time today and possibly won't get back, will throw a proxy vote in just in case.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Friar Tuck - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 07:04 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: Been watching the back and forth between Dora and Friar, my vote will definitely be going on one of them. Haven't had much time today and possibly won't get back, will throw a proxy vote in just in case.
Who else would you put it on in fairness?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Zeena Warrior Princess - 18-01-2023

I'm leaning towards voting for Friar tonight

I'm confident one of them, friar or Dora is a triator. Ideally we hit the traitor tonight but if not we should have a certain one tomorrow. A villager would take it on the chin more than a triator, which of you would volunteer more?

How are we for number for mislynching?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 07:41 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote: I'm leaning towards voting for Friar tonight

I'm confident one of them, friar or Dora is a triator. Ideally we hit the traitor tonight but if not we should have a certain one tomorrow. A villager would take it on the chin more than a triator, which of you would volunteer more?

How are we for number for mislynching?

numbers don't work the same as ww.
night kills end before it comes to parity, and end game begins.
in end game, you have just two questions, which foloow each other until game is over, 1) would you like the game to end, need unanimous to end game, a single, no, let continue, means 2)  the game goes on to another banishment vote. after that vote, go to 1)


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Zeena Warrior Princess - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:06 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 07:41 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote: I'm leaning towards voting for Friar tonight

I'm confident one of them, friar or Dora is a triator. Ideally we hit the traitor tonight but if not we should have a certain one tomorrow. A villager would take it on the chin more than a triator, which of you would volunteer more?

How are we for number for mislynching?

numbers don't work the same as ww.
night kills end before it comes to parity, and end game begins.
in end game, you have just two questions, which foloow each other until game is over, 1) would you like the game to end, need unanimous to end game, a single, no, let continue, means 2)  the game goes on to another banishment vote. after that vote, go to 1)

So if we mislynch tonight, we could have 6 players left tomorrow. I think at most there would be 3 wolves, that would leave us at parity. So the end game could start tomorrow?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:16 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:06 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote: numbers don't work the same as ww.
night kills end before it comes to parity, and end game begins.
in end game, you have just two questions, which foloow each other until game is over, 1) would you like the game to end, need unanimous to end game, a single, no, let continue, means 2)  the game goes on to another banishment vote. after that vote, go to 1)

So if we mislynch tonight, we could have 6 players left tomorrow. I think at most there would be 3 wolves, that would leave us at parity. So the end game could start tomorrow?

thats why i don't think there was ever 3 traitors, as we'd already be in end game.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Moe the Innkeeper - 18-01-2023

Friar was my 2nd most suspect after Edward yesterday. They knew they were a massive lynch target today so this could well be a desperate play to eek an extra day out of a traitor. If I look at friars action with an assumption they are not a wolf I can see why they would want to confirm their suspicion of dora. However looking at it that friar is a traitor its probably worth a punt to try and set up dora and hope for the misslynch (even with my most suspect hat on surely they can't both be traitors!) I still don't really understand why they put just William as a suspect with dora when myself and wayland had similar vote patterns to william. Friar tried to explain it but I don't understand

Said this yesterday too but I hadn't seen anything overly traitor in dora. It's so hard to tell from the back and forth between dora and friar but my head is saying that friar is bad. Only thing going for them is that they have got their vote in early each evening and nailed colours to the mast, so a little bit of me is thinking again there is possibility of faithful there. Dora voted 2 faithful and friar voted 1 faithful and 1 unknown

Head saying friar is traitor, voting pattern leans slightly to dora, that's where I am

These prizes are a headwreck


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Weyland the Blacksmith - 18-01-2023

Sorry guys shit has hit the fan in work so sorting that out. I will leave a vote with Necro   Be back tomorrow.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Weyland the Blacksmith - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:16 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:06 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote: numbers don't work the same as ww.
night kills end before it comes to parity, and end game begins.
in end game, you have just two questions, which foloow each other until game is over, 1) would you like the game to end, need unanimous to end game, a single, no, let continue, means 2)  the game goes on to another banishment vote. after that vote, go to 1)

So if we mislynch tonight, we could have 6 players left tomorrow. I think at most there would be 3 wolves, that would leave us at parity. So the end game could start tomorrow?

There is no parity in this game. Have a look at the OP.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:18 PM)Moe the Innkeeper Wrote: Friar was my 2nd most suspect after Edward yesterday. They knew they were a massive lynch target today so this could well be a desperate play to eek an extra day out of a traitor. If I look at friars action with an assumption they are not a wolf I can see why they would want to confirm their suspicion of dora. However looking at it that friar is a traitor its probably worth a punt to try and set up dora and hope for the misslynch (even with my most suspect hat on surely they can't both be traitors!) I still don't really understand why they put just William as a suspect with dora when myself and wayland had similar vote patterns to william. Friar tried to explain it but I don't understand

Said this yesterday too but I hadn't seen anything overly traitor in dora. It's so hard to tell from the back and forth between dora and friar but my head is saying that friar is bad. Only thing going for them is that they have got their vote in early each evening and nailed colours to the mast, so a little bit of me is thinking again there is possibility of faithful there. Dora voted 2 faithful and friar voted 1 faithful and 1 unknown

Head saying friar is traitor, voting pattern leans slightly to dora, that's where I am

These prizes are a headwreck


>voting pattern leans slightly to dora

I don't agree.

they both voted a villager day 1, that's why they are both in this mess.

friar voted early, but that is not alignment indicative. 

dora had no choice. They had to vote edward. A self pres vote is not alignment indicative.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:24 PM)Weyland the Blacksmith Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:16 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote: So if we mislynch tonight, we could have 6 players left tomorrow. I think at most there would be 3 wolves, that would leave us at parity. So the end game could start tomorrow?

There is no parity in this game. Have a look at the OP.
 parity means when the sides are level. there is parity, even if that does not trigger anything.
if the wolves ever out number the village, they just keep banishing the faithful by voting together.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Moe the Innkeeper - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:29 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:18 PM)Moe the Innkeeper Wrote: Friar was my 2nd most suspect after Edward yesterday. They knew they were a massive lynch target today so this could well be a desperate play to eek an extra day out of a traitor. If I look at friars action with an assumption they are not a wolf I can see why they would want to confirm their suspicion of dora. However looking at it that friar is a traitor its probably worth a punt to try and set up dora and hope for the misslynch (even with my most suspect hat on surely they can't both be traitors!) I still don't really understand why they put just William as a suspect with dora when myself and wayland had similar vote patterns to william. Friar tried to explain it but I don't understand

Said this yesterday too but I hadn't seen anything overly traitor in dora. It's so hard to tell from the back and forth between dora and friar but my head is saying that friar is bad. Only thing going for them is that they have got their vote in early each evening and nailed colours to the mast, so a little bit of me is thinking again there is possibility of faithful there. Dora voted 2 faithful and friar voted 1 faithful and 1 unknown

Head saying friar is traitor, voting pattern leans slightly to dora, that's where I am

These prizes are a headwreck


>voting pattern leans slightly to dora

I don't agree.

they both voted a villager day 1, that's why they are both in this mess.

friar voted early, but that is not alignment indicative. 

dora had no choice. They had to vote edward. A self pres vote is not alignment indicative.
I agree that a faithful can self pres in that situation, that's why it's only slightly and not more. I'm just trying to piece it together with the info we have, and that's how I'm looking at it

What do you think?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Friar Tuck - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:29 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:18 PM)Moe the Innkeeper Wrote: Friar was my 2nd most suspect after Edward yesterday. They knew they were a massive lynch target today so this could well be a desperate play to eek an extra day out of a traitor. If I look at friars action with an assumption they are not a wolf I can see why they would want to confirm their suspicion of dora. However looking at it that friar is a traitor its probably worth a punt to try and set up dora and hope for the misslynch (even with my most suspect hat on surely they can't both be traitors!) I still don't really understand why they put just William as a suspect with dora when myself and wayland had similar vote patterns to william. Friar tried to explain it but I don't understand

Said this yesterday too but I hadn't seen anything overly traitor in dora. It's so hard to tell from the back and forth between dora and friar but my head is saying that friar is bad. Only thing going for them is that they have got their vote in early each evening and nailed colours to the mast, so a little bit of me is thinking again there is possibility of faithful there. Dora voted 2 faithful and friar voted 1 faithful and 1 unknown

Head saying friar is traitor, voting pattern leans slightly to dora, that's where I am

These prizes are a headwreck


>voting pattern leans slightly to dora

I don't agree.

they both voted a villager day 1, that's why they are both in this mess.

friar voted early, but that is not alignment indicative. 

dora had no choice. They had to vote edward. A self pres vote is not alignment indicative.
What do think of Dora saying she considered voting for Countess last night even though I was her preferred choice?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 08:06 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 07:41 PM)Zeena Warrior Princess Wrote: I'm leaning towards voting for Friar tonight

I'm confident one of them, friar or Dora is a triator. Ideally we hit the traitor tonight but if not we should have a certain one tomorrow. A villager would take it on the chin more than a triator, which of you would volunteer more?

How are we for number for mislynching?

numbers don't work the same as ww.
night kills end before it comes to parity, and end game begins.
in end game, you have just two questions, which foloow each other until game is over, 1) would you like the game to end, need unanimous to end game, a single, no, let continue, means 2)  the game goes on to another banishment vote. after that vote, go to 1)


That's actually a good point, I had forgotten that in my hammer talk earlier on. A hammer would reveal the wolves and then it would be down to chance whether or not they won because surely the faithful would all vote for the same wolf and the wolves would vote for the same faithful each vote and it would be chance.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 09:02 PM)Friar Tuck Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 08:29 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote: >voting pattern leans slightly to dora

I don't agree.

they both voted a villager day 1, that's why they are both in this mess.

friar voted early, but that is not alignment indicative. 

dora had no choice. They had to vote edward. A self pres vote is not alignment indicative.
What do think of Dora saying she considered voting for Countess last night even though I was her preferred choice?

I like it.

Its way different than the fire in a vote and disappear we seen the night before.

In a twist of faith, It is doras uncertainness that I can see faithful in.

i'd have like to have seen that on night 1 after her vote was laid down, but she wasn't around for us to see then, but as you say, day 2 voting was different, they were dynamic with their vote, willing to put is to use, and to maybe even try to get a three way tie vs a coin flip.

on the f;ip side, your vote went down pretty quick, maybe you have agreed beforehand where you would put your vote, so you couldn't play fast and loose with it, or you'd upset your partner and they could screw you today.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Friar Tuck - 18-01-2023

(18-01-2023, 09:12 PM)Gordon the Cook Wrote:
(18-01-2023, 09:02 PM)Friar Tuck Wrote: What do think of Dora saying she considered voting for Countess last night even though I was her preferred choice?

I like it.

Its way different than the fire in a vote and disappear we seen the night before.

In a twist of faith, It is doras uncertainness that I can see faithful in.

i'd have like to have seen that on night 1 after her vote was laid down, but she wasn't around for us to see then, but as you say, day 2 voting was different, they were dynamic with their vote, willing to put is to use, and to maybe even try to get a three way tie vs a coin flip.

on the f;ip side, your vote went down pretty quick, maybe you have agreed beforehand where you would put your vote, so you couldn't play fast and loose with it, or you'd upset your partner and they could screw you today.
Mine went down quickly because I thought dora was a wolf. It's on the thread, I don't have a partner to discuss it with.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Countess Markievicz - 18-01-2023

Guys, stop being so reasonable and nice about this, one of you should be nasty and wolfy so we know which to banish.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 18-01-2023

Countess it's the one who is lying who is the wolfy one. I'd hope it's clear enough who that one is.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 18-01-2023

Voting is now OPEN


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 18-01-2023

William the Grave Robber casts a proxy vote for Dora the Explorer


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Necro - 18-01-2023

Weyland the Blacksmith casts a proxy vote for Dora the Explorer


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Friar Tuck - 18-01-2023

Vote Dora


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 18-01-2023

Vote Friar


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Zeena Warrior Princess - 18-01-2023

Im having second thoughts on friar, he could have kept stumm and not bring attention to himself if he is a triator. Dora flips good we immediately go after him

Gordo, moe, countess, what ye think?


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Dora the Explorer - 18-01-2023

If anyone tries to weasel out of voting for Friar if I get banished is a wolf too.


RE: Round Table Discussion Thread - Gordon the Cook - 18-01-2023

how many alive today?