A sheep, a werewolf and a walrus walk into a bar.

Based roughly on the Today FMs Dermot & Dave's format.

The rules are simple - two songs face off against each other, one very cheesy and one an absolute cracker. 

Votes are via Thanks, and you can only vote for either the cheese or the cracker, and vote runs for 1 day.

The winner chooses the next cheese and nominates an opponent to choose the cracker. 

If you'd like to participate, thank this post! 

I'll kick off with the first cheese and nomination at midday.

Welcome to our first match up for Cheese and Crackers! First up, me with the cheese and @Kol with the cracker, winner will be the most thanked by midday tomorrow. Remember you can only vote for either the cheese or the cracker, much lighthearted music choice banter welcome! 


Our inaugural cheese is... 




@Kol please grace us with the inaugural cracker, I've no doubt I'll be fighting a losing battle!

What a puntastic thread title nothing.

Cracker: Fleetwood Mac - Go Your Own Way

Ooof, I knew I'd be in trouble, but dammmmmn I'd nearly vote against myself here!

Just over 90 minutes left to vote on our first round - it's currently 6 to 1 for the cracker, Fleetwood Mac absolutely obliterating the cheese, Hanson!

@Kol takes it out, with an epic cracker choice!

@Kol choose your opponent from those who thanked the opening post who will nominate an absolute cracker, and choose the best cheesy tune you enjoy!

I nominate @Butty Brennan as the player who thanked me first yesterday

and now for the cheese

All-4-One - I Swear

My cracker: Just A Girl by No Doubt

Ooh tough but excellent choices on both counts, but the cracker just edged it for me!

I'm torn I do like both but Gwen and Co., takes it for me

@Kol , voted for you because you can be sure I know my part, 'cause I'll stand beside you through the years

(07-03-2022, 11:35 PM)E.N. Wrote: [ -> ]@Kol , voted for you because you can be sure I know my part, 'cause I'll stand beside you through the years

We'll never walk alone

Congrats @Butty Brennan on a 6-3 victory!

Woot!  
I think you have to go back to the 80s for the big cheese so here is:
Kenny Loggins - Footloose


I will nominate the next thanker in line to choose a cracker @Rachel Stevens on a Pogo Stick

Oooh that's some cheesy cheese! Excellent

CRACKER:

R.E.M. - Losing My Religion

Wow, excellent cracker choice! Think I'll need a few listens to both to decide

Cracker takes it for me, again! Loved the cheese, but it just missed it by a hair!

Not trying to be a hipster, but it's genuinely one of my least favourite REM songs. I still love it, though. They were the first gig I ever went to, got to stick with them

Kenny Loggins knew catchy tunes, cheese for me here

Cheese wins 5 to 2! Great choice @Butty Brennan, you're up again, give us another cheese and nomination

Double woot!  
Here's the Cheese:
The Weather Girls - It's Raining Men

@jp liz v1 to choose a cracker please.

I think this is a cracker by Disturbed

Simon and Garfunkel would have got my vote

@Butty Brennan wins and @ShaneU you can go next too if that ok with @nothing

(10-03-2022, 01:54 PM)jp liz v1 Wrote: [ -> ]@Butty Brennan  wins and @ShaneU you can go next too if that ok with @nothing

Winner's choice, Butty has excellent cheese taste!

(10-03-2022, 03:03 PM)nothing Wrote: [ -> ]

(10-03-2022, 01:54 PM)jp liz v1 Wrote: [ -> ]@Butty Brennan  wins and @ShaneU you can go next too if that ok with @nothing

Winner's choice, Butty has excellent cheese taste!

Sorry @nothing  @Butty Brennan

no need to apologise liz!

Woohoo! Three in a row. Now I know how Necro feels.
Here's another serving of cheese (and may God have mercy on my soul)  

If @ShaneU would like to choose a cracker please go ahead.

Butty, you're on a roll, and you know your cheese!

Cracker:

Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps

Maps is an absolute belter

It would have taken my vote anyway, but I really like Dancing in the Street and don't think it's that cheesy at all... 🤔

(10-03-2022, 05:17 PM)E.N. Wrote: [ -> ]Maps is an absolute belter

It would have taken my vote anyway, but I really like Dancing in the Street and don't think it's that cheesy at all... 🤔

There's definitely some subjectivity to what makes a song cheesy or a cracker, but I guess it's going to depend on your own taste at times!

I'll have a cracker I suppose

@ShaneU takes it from @Butty Brennan with 5 to 3 votes. Can he hang onto the title with some cheese? Choose your cheese and opponent!

I was singing along to this on the radio earlier

Cheese: Lighthouse Family - High



I nominate @Homer J. Fong for the cracker

Thank you for the nom Shane, ask and ye shall receive!

Inspired by a recent Heardle, my cracker is:

Outkast - Ms. Jackson

Lighthouse Family vs Outkast